Comparisons
Comparisons
Almost every familiar way of working in crafts now has a digital alternative. But replacing is not the same as improving: sometimes pencil and paper are more reliable than any app, and sometimes a video explains in a minute what takes a whole page in a book. The tables below help you work out what suits you.
The best method is the one that makes you stop working least often just to figure out where you are.
How to read the tables: we compare approaches, not specific devices or programs. Many people combine both options, and that is perfectly fine.
Paper chart vs chart on screen
| Criterion | Paper chart | Chart on screen |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of reading | You see the whole chart at once; small squares depend on print quality | You can zoom in on the part you need, but the whole page is harder to see |
| Markings | Pencil, highlighter and a ruler or strip under the row | Annotations on the file or on a working copy; the original stays clean |
| Reliance on technology | None: it never goes dark or runs out of battery | Needs charge, and the screen may go dark mid-row |
| Storage | Sheets get creased, lost and take up space | Fits in a folder and is easy to back up |
| Best for | People who like to see the whole pattern and draw right on the chart | People who knit on the go, need a large view and keep many charts |
Video vs written pattern
| Criterion | Video | Written pattern |
|---|---|---|
| A new technique | You see the hand movements straight away, which makes them easier to copy | You have to work through the wording and abbreviations |
| Pace | Can be slowed down, but you have to hunt for the right moment | You read at your own pace and easily go back to a line |
| For left-handers | Mirroring the picture helps | You have to reverse the instructions in your head |
| Following along as you knit | Awkward to keep open for the whole project | Works well for markings and counting rows |
| Best for | People learning a technique for the first time who remember things visually | People who already know the basics and are working on a large project |
App counter vs paper counter
| Criterion | App counter | Paper counter |
|---|---|---|
| Speed of marking | A single tap on a large button | A pencil tally mark; you have to pick up the pencil |
| Several counts at once | Usually lets you track rows and pattern repeats separately | Separate columns on the sheet |
| Risk of losing count | An accidental tap, a reset or a flat battery | A lost sheet or an illegible mark |
| Distraction | Notifications on the same screen break your concentration | Nothing to distract you |
| Best for | People who already keep their chart on the phone | People who knit from a paper chart or prefer no screen nearby |
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step advice: a chart on a tablet, learning from videos, storing notes, photographing by the window, ordering yarn online. Plus the article catalogue.
- Tools
What to keep within reach: a screen that makes charts easy to read, a stand, a row counter, folders, a backup and good light for photos.
- Problems
Lost your place in the chart, the colour looks wrong in a photo, the video is too fast, the file will not open, the screen goes dark mid-row.
- Glossary
Plain-English glossary: chart, pattern repeat, chart symbols, yarn over, pick up stitches, dye lot, white balance, backup.
- Questions
Answers about the guide, about charts and videos, about photos of finished pieces and about etiquette in crafting communities.
Sources
- Knitting and crafting reference books (in general terms)
- Help sections of apps and devices (in general terms)
- Iskussnica editorial materials
The guide is written in general terms and reflects the editors' view as of the date it was prepared. Phones, tablets and apps all work a little differently, and menu items move or get renamed from time to time. If your device's own help pages or the pattern designer recommend something different from us, follow their advice.